Harry Wong
Jan 2017
Vol 14 No 1

Why Johnny Can’t Read – The Distinction Between Vowel and Consonant Generalizations

By Teachers.Net Community

The following was posted  by Mark Andrejevic to one of the more-than 150 Teachers.Net mailrings:

My mother — a longtime teacher has posted an article that refutes the current tendency to blame reading teachers for a system that is, in many respects, beyond their control. She outlines what she sees as the problem and one possible solution. She is interested in feedback from people involved in teaching reading, so I thought I’d circulate the link and ask those who are interested to take a look at the article.

Here is the introduction:

“Recently it has become popular among a number of politicians and philanthropists who consider themselves education reformers, and even the general public to blame teachers for the undeniably low reading scores and lagging performance in America’s schools.  Geoffrey Canada (CEO of The Harlem Children’s Zone, and the major figure in the much-hyped movie Waiting For Superman) claims that once teachers get tenure and are assured of reasonable working conditions and salaries, they stop exerting themselves in the classroom and just let the children teach themselves.  This view of teachers has resulted in calls to abolish teacher tenure and dismiss those teachers whose students earn the lowest reading scores.

Anyone who has taught in an inner city urban school knows that most teachers work very hard indeed. For the great majority of teachers these negative judgments on their work are discouraging, frustrating and close to libelous.  But the most frustrating part of this scenario is that the real cause of failing schools and low reading scores is neither the teachers, the parents, nor the children, but the continuing disarray in the field of American  reading instruction.  It has been many years since American teachers were free to teach children this essential academic skill as they thought best. Today teachers put their job at risk if they deviate from the currently approved method while simultaneously being blamed for that method’s poor results, which in turn influence every aspect of education.”

The complete article is available online at:

I hope this is of interest to the list.
All the best,
Mark –



Comment on this article...

Next Article...
This entry was posted on Thursday, March 1st, 2012 and is filed under *ISSUES, March 2012, Teachers.Net Community. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. Both comments and pings are currently closed.
Teachers.Net Gazette Vol.9 No.3 March 2012

Harry & Rosemary Wong: Effective Teaching
The Highest Rated School in NYC (Pt 2)
Collective efforts will produce greater results for students, and rankings reflect this.

Cover Story by Brad Johnson
Politics of Education
The media and many politicians seem to think that many teachers are lazy and incompetent....

»Stop Teaching! Let Kids Teach Themselves - Third in the "Two-Word" SeriesBill Page
»The Importance of Assertiveness in TeachersRobert Rose
»Centering - A Perfect Metaphor for the Interaction of Student, Teacher, Time, MaterialsTodd Nelson
»Helping the Sexually Abused ChildLeah Davies
»Facilitation Keys for Effective Classroom Management - Coaching the Urban EducatorAndrea Cleveland
»St. Patrick's Leprechaun Magic, Dr. Seuss, Read Across America Day Activities
»Make St. Patrick's Day Parade Shakers! Karen's PreK PageKaren Cox
»Favorite Math Manipulatives - Gr. 2
»Getting the Most Out of Young Writers
»14 Kindergarten Math Center Activities
»Education and Technology - Some Thoughts on Assessment: "Is this going to count for marks?"Craig Frehlich
»Marjan's 5 GREAT Sites for Busy EducatorsMarjan Glavac
»Botany in the News - Rich Resources for Teachers
»Positive Performing People: A Teacher's Behavior Management Technique for Learning Disabled StudentsSuzanne Vitanza
»Ideas to Increase Parent Involvement
»Josie Whitehead's Second Career: Writing Rhyming Poems for Teachers and Children
»New Book for Children Teaches 7 Continents: Amy's Travels
»Teaching About the Federal Reserve Bank
»How to Draw a LadybugTim Newlin
»Why Can't Johnny Read: The Distinction Between Vowel and Consonant Generalizations
»Is THIS What Teachers Do??
»The Four Leaf Clover and Educational SerendipityShama Noman
»Apple Seeds Quotes - A Month of Them!Barb Stutesman
»Today is... Special Events, Days in March
»Submit Your Teaching Tips, Articles, Photographs to Teachers.Net Gazette!
»PreK - 12 Printables
»March News & Notes
»Are Some School Administrators Afraid of Outstanding Teachers?

By State
AL   AK   AZ   AR   CA   CO   CT   DE   DC   FL   GA   HI   ID   IL   IN   IA   KS   KY   LA    ME   MD   MA   MI   MN   MS   MO   MT   NE   NV   NH   NJ   NM   NY   NC   ND   OH   OK   OR   PA   RI   SC   SD   TN   TX   UT   VT     VA   WA   WV   WI   WY